MENTAL HEALTH IN OUR COMMUNITY
THE CHAS FOUNDATION 2019 YEAR IN REVIEW • theCHASfoundation.org 5
In a 1988 article in the Mobile, Ala. Press-
Register, “Mother Cannot Make Son Well,”
my courageous mother, Irene Frazer, spoke
out.
“It’s such a tragedy. It’s just a tragedy to see
this beautiful personality that you adore
dissolve into something you cannot fathom,”
she said.
Over the headline, Dr. John P. Callan, medical
director of Family Services for McHenry
County, Libertyville, IL, was also quoted: “The
most important issue facing psychiatry today
is the plight of the chronically mentally ill and
funding their treatment.”
My mother was talking about my amazing
brother, John Frazer. The article went on to
say: “The Frazers’ son held the potential of joining the community
leaders. Instead, as a teenager, he developed a serious mental
illness, schizophrenia. Mrs. Frazer said minor symptoms of mental
illness developed in her son during his junior year in high school.”
Despite the changes in his personality, John was accepted at
Tulane University and several other colleges. He chose Tulane and
stayed one year. As my mother noted, he failed most of his work
and came home. It took three months to get him to the appropriate
psychiatrist.
The article goes on to state: “Mrs. Frazer said, ‘schizophrenia
is a no-fault brain disease and the onset of it comes at a very
devastating age when a person is just developing from adolescence
into maturity at about age 16 or 17 to 21.’”
Where is John today? At age 67, he lives in a senior community
in an independent apartment. He a gentle giant, overweight due
to the side effects of his medications. Slow, withdrawn, catatonic
and extremely quiet, he has never raised a violent word or attitude
against himself or anyone else. He is described by the staff and
residents of Somerby of West Mobile as a “blessing,” an “angel” and
a very “polite gentleman” with “excellent manners.”
Every day, he slowly performs errands that the staff gives him,
positing notices around the building and in the elevators. He
delivers packages and mail to ill residents, takes art lessons
and runs the bingo game on Saturday night. He has never once
complained about his illness or any other daily
frustrations we all face. His apartment stays
immaculately clean.
Where is our country today in treatment for
the mentally ill? Not much has changed since
1988. The medications, though improved,
have not advanced a lot since the 1950s.
There is no cure for this lifetime disease.
Although one in four families experience
some form of mental illness in their loved
ones, there is no protocol for treatment of
the mentally ill like there is for other major
diseases including cancer, heart diseases or
stroke.
In fact, under the current leadership, instead
of improving conditions for the mentally ill, it
seems we are heading in the opposite direction.
I was deeply disturbed to read an article in the Sept. 10 Virginian-
Pilot about a proposal from former NBC chairman Bob Wright
to President Donald Trump. This idea would establish an agency,
HARPA, the Health Advanced Research Projects Agency, that
would tag the mentally ill with devices such as smartwatches to
predict violence. The article noted the president has repeatedly
pointed to mental illness as the cause of frequent mass shootings
in the United States. It also noted that experts say those with
severe mental illness are much more likely to be victims rather than
perpetrators of gun violence.
How would smartwatch wrist band impact John, who has absolutely
no history of violence? Articial intelligence technology is not
perfect. What if John fell or tripped and the violence predictor in
the device was set off?
Would he be sent to a detention facility for the mentally ill? Or
sterilized, as was the practice during the eugenics movement in
Virginia in the 1920s and ’30s?
Instead of funding HARPA, why not fund the research for a cure of
mental illness; invest in improved medications; fund more hospital
beds for those who are chronically ill instead of housing them in jails
which is where most of the mentally ill live these days?
Where is our humanity? As far as the mentally ill are concerned, we
can certainly do better.
Letter to the Editor by CHAS Board Member, Margaret Ballard
As published in The Virginian-Pilot on October 6, 2019.
Aaron Ambrose
Dr. Paul Aravich
Margaret Ballard
Ryan Bose
Missy Callahan
Margaret Corprew
David Faircloth
Fred Fitch
Ian Holder
Dr. J. Mark Lawson
Jane Steinhilber
BOARD OF DIRECTORS