Departmental Preliminary Doctoral Oral Examination
This exam is intended to review the student's proposed research plan and determine that the student is
academically prepared to undertake the schoolwide preliminary oral exam and to carry out thesis research. The
examination provides the student with experience in discussing a research proposal in a formal setting that
resembles the School's preliminary oral. It also is a mechanism to review the rigor of the proposed research,
independent of the oral performance, and to provide the student with constructive commentary on the strengths
and weaknesses of the proposed research, as well as strengths and weaknesses in PFRH content and research
design and methods in general. Students are expected to begin with a 10-minute PowerPoint presentation
summarizing their proposed research.
In order to sit for the departmental oral examination a student must have completed all required coursework and
passed the written and oral components of the Department Comprehensive Examination. Students are also
expected to complete a thesis proposal in preparation for the exam. This proposal is completed while working
closely with their advisor, co-advisor, if there is one, and department faculty, as appropriate, to determine if the
thesis proposal is of adequate rigor before proceeding to the oral exam. The faculty advisor (and co-advisor) is
expected to have thoroughly reviewed the proposal and have approved its quality prior to scheduling the
examination. Other examiners or department faculty are not responsible for approving the proposal prior to the
examination, but consultation from faculty other than the advisor is recommended, as appropriate.
In addition to working with their advisor(s), students are expected to take advantage of the proposal writing
seminar. It provides an opportunity to receive feedback from fellow students and the seminar instructor about
their proposed research and proposal. Examples of proposals are available for student review in the proposal
writing course website and provide models of the expected rigor. Sample proposals are also available for faculty
review (see Education Office). Students are expected to discuss feedback received during the proposal writing
seminar with their advisor (and co-advisor).
The Departmental Oral Examination is typically scheduled at least one month before the Schoolwide Preliminary
Oral Examination. It may be wise to begin contacting faculty about service on the schoolwide oral exam
committee before the departmental oral so that paperwork for the schoolwide exam can be submitted shortly
after the departmental oral exam is successfully concluded with an unconditional pass. On the other hand, time
between the two exams may be advised for students whose proposal may need additional refinement or for
students who may need additional preparation in answering questions in an oral exam.
The Departmental Oral Committee should include four members of the PFRH faculty including the student’s thesis
advisor (and co-advisor). In the rare exception, a student may request to have a committee of three members; this
request will not be granted for students with co-advisors. It is important that not all members of the committee
have been involved in the student’s proposal, so that the student has the opportunity for the proposal to be
evaluated by a faculty member not involved in the project and or research. If a PFRH faculty member (not including
the student’s advisor) has agreed to serve on the Schoolwide Oral Committee, then that person must also serve as
a member of the Departmental Oral Committee. Faculty with joint appointments in PFRH whose primary
appointment is in another University department may serve on the Departmental Oral Committee, but only if they
are not serving as outside members of the Schoolwide Oral Committee. Students cannot have more than three
members from the Department Preliminary Oral Examination on the Schoolwide Preliminary Oral Examination; co-
advisors are two of the three department faculty.
The student and his/her advisor select the committee members for this exam.
The student is responsible for scheduling the exam and a room, reserving multimedia equipment (e.g. laptop,
computer) and filing appropriate administrative forms provided by the Academic Program Manager at least one
month prior to date of exam. Department room reservations can be scheduled through the Academic Program
Manager. Multimedia equipment can be reserved through the Department Chair’s Office.